The Virtues of War (ISBN 9780553382051) by Steven Pressfield is quite an unorthodox book. As opposed to so
many history or fiction books, including novels, about Alexander, this one lets Alexander
speak for himself – a very challenging enterprise.
Steven
Pressfield, who I learned to appreciate in his novel The
Afghan Campaign, clearly warns his readers in the introductory note
that he does not follow history according to the strict reports but has arranged the events and facts to better suit his own interpretation, i.e., the true
spirit of Alexander as he conceives
it.
In this novel, Alexander is talking to Itanes, the younger brother of Roxane,
who has joined his ranks to be at this stage taken into his close circle of
Companions.
It is not a
sentimental tale but a story told from the point of view of a general, a
military leader who knows his men inside out. Alexander’s strategies and awareness of what happens around him
in battle without seeing how events unfold outside his narrow perimeter are almost palpable. Far from being a monotonous monologue, Alexander shares not only his battle memories in facts and figures but also relates other key moments, of which there were many. He
talks about his soldiers’ experiencing life in Babylon,
the conspiracy of Philotas
and the subsequent execution of his father Parmenion,
the need to reshape his army facing guerilla war in Bactria, and how by the
time he reaches India, more than half of his Macedonian troops have been
replaced by foreign entities. The character of Alexander that transpires is that of a king in all its complexity but
also that of a man who realizes he is not perfect and often falls short.
Besides, he is very well aware that the attitude and mindset of people in the
East is very different from that in Greece and that he inevitably has
to adapt – something his marshals cannot comprehend.
Hephaistion is well portrayed, always appearing at Alexander’s side. Historians generally tune his presence
down simply because ancient writers have ignored him for whatever reason
(perhaps his story was not juicy enough?). The description of the other
commanders like Parmenion,
Craterus,
Black
Cleitus, Ptolemy,
Peucestas,
Seleucos,
Philotas,
and dozens of others is very recognizable.
King
Philip II of Macedonia remains Alexander’s
great role model throughout the story as young Alexander kept his eyes open and clearly understood his father’s
policy and tactics. The influence of Olympias,
which is often impressed on the character of Alexander, is absent. This is a man’s world.
As in The
Afghan Campaign, I marvel at Steven Pressfield’s knowledge of the
military and the mindset of the troops in the field and on the march. Looking
him up on Wikipedia,
I read that his book Gates of Fire
(which I have not read – yet) is being taught at Westpoint,
the U.S.
Naval Academy, and the Marine Corps Basic School
at Quantico. He is a man to my heart, knowing that Alexander’s Battle
of Gaugamela is still teaching material at Westpoint!
I honestly don’t
understand why this book is being underrated. This is not just another history
of Alexander the Great but a very
worthwhile attempt to crawl inside his mind and under his skin. Steven
Pressfield made a superb effort to understand how the mind of a great man works.
Since Alexander falls within the
category of the geniuses, who among us dare criticize when the author lets a
genius speak?
No comments:
Post a Comment