Alexandria's founded by Alexander

Alexandria's founded by Alexander the Great (by year BC): 334 Alexandria in Troia (Turkey) - 333 Alexandria at Issus/Alexandrette (Iskenderun, Turkey) - 332 Alexandria of Caria/by the Latmos (Alinda, Turkey) - 331 Alexandria Mygdoniae - 331 Alexandria (Egypt) - 330 Alexandria Ariana (Herat, Afghanistan) - 330 Alexandria of the Prophthasia/in Dragiana/Phrada (Farah, Afghanistan) - 330 Alexandria in Arachosia (Kandahar, Afghanistan) - 330 Alexandria in the Caucasus (Begram, Afghanistan) - 329 Alexandria of the Paropanisades (Ghazni, Afghanistan) - 329 Alexandria Eschate or Ultima (Khodjend, Tajikistan) - 329 Alexandria on the Oxus (Termez, Afghanistan) - 328 Alexandria in Margiana (Merv, Turkmenistan) - 326 Alexandria Nicaea (on the Hydaspes, India) - 326 Alexandria Bucephala (on the Hydaspes, India) - 325 Alexandria Sogdia - 325 Alexandria Oreitide - 325 Alexandria in Opiene / Alexandria on the Indus (confluence of Indus & Acesines, India) - 325 Alexandria Rambacia (Bela, Pakistan) - 325 Alexandria Xylinepolis (Patala, India) - 325 Alexandria in Carminia (Gulashkird, Iran) - 324 Alexandria-on-the-Tigris/Antiochia-in-Susiana/Charax (Spasinou Charax on the Tigris, Iraq) - ?Alexandria of Carmahle? (Kahnu)

Tuesday, October 17, 2023

Planetarium of Archimedes?

A fragment from a complex mechanism was discovered by chance near Olbia, Sardinia, and it soon became clear that the dented gear wheel showed similarities with the mechanism of Anticythera. This fragment, however, was made of a brass alloy unknown otherwise at the time. 


Thanks to the detailed writings of Cicero in the 1st century BC, we know that Archimedes constructed a Planetarium (Orrery). The celestial globe is mentioned by Ovid in the 1st century BC and by Claudian, a 4th-century Latin poet associated with the court of Emperor Honorius in Mediolanum (Milan). 

When, in 212 BC, the Romans sacked Syracuse, Consul Marcus Claudius Marcellus brought to Rome a device that was built by the famous mathematician. It represented the motion of the Sun, Moon, and the planets reproduced on a sphere. In short, a modern Planetarium. 

It was Gaius Sulpicius Gallus, who reported the story as he had seen the object personally and knew how to operate it. Cicero was amazed that Archimedes had been able to generate the motion of the individual planets starting from a single rotation. The Planetarium was placed inside a glass sphere. This corresponds to what Archimedes wrote in a now-lost treatise On Sphere-Making detailing the construction of the Planetarium. 

Livy, who died in 17 AD, wrote that before the Battle of Pydna in 168 BC, Gallus, an astronomer himself, used the Planetarium to predict a lunar eclipse on the night before the battle. The news was shared with his Roman legionnaires to prevent them from panicking, but the Macedonians freaked out. 

A first reconstruction based on the section of the gear wheel found near Olbia revealed that it counted 55 dents in total. Noteworthy is the shape of the dents, which is not triangular as in the case of the Anticythera mechanism but slightly curved as used in our modern gear wheels. This shape proves to be more efficient and allows a higher precision. In antiquity, these wheels were created manually and the craftsmen had to do without the use of our modern measuring and cutting tools, which emerged only a few centuries ago. 

Marcus Claudius Marcellus, owner of the Planetarium, was sent off to Spain to fight the Iberic Celts in 152 BC. It is reasonable to assume that Marcellus took the Planetarium with him – a sign of his status – and that his ship was wrecked in the region of Olbia, crashing the Planetarium. 

The Planetarium has been dated between the end of the 3rd century BC and the mid-2nd century BC. It thus predates the Anticythera mechanism from the 1st century BC generally ascribed to Archimedes. However, the analog computer may well have been reproduced based on Archimedes’ description.

It must have been one of the marvels from Hellenistic times, many of which still remain to be discovered!

[the section found near Olbia is thoroughly discussed in this YouTube]

3 comments:

  1. Attribute the Olbia mechanism to Archimedes is obviously a hypothesis,but only a hypothesis. Why Marcus Claudius Marcellus should have brought with him a such a voluminous and delicate mechanism? Furthermore Cicero said that he see the Archimedes planetarium in the Marcelli's domus at his time. The problem is thinking that in Hellenistic times was only one a isolated genius,Archimedes; this is not true. In III century BC the research centers were many..was underway a scientific and technological revolution. Alexandria, Syracuse, Rhodes ,Pergamum,Carthage. In the same Syracuse Archimedes was not the only scientist or (as they were called) "mechanic". So the Olbia mechanism was for sure from some computation device...one of the many built in III century BC. P.S. if you create your a whish list i'm glad to give yourself a copy of "Forgotten revolution" of Lucio Russo,for exemple the paperback edition from 71,25.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Nothing is carved in stone when we talk in history about what was and what wasn’t.
      If Marcellus had the Archimedes planetarium at his home as written by Cicero, he moved it from Syracuse to Rome. So why wouldn’t he take it with him from Rome to Spain?
      Now, whether it was made by Archimedes or by one of the many other scientists of his time remains an open question. The Antikythera “computer” has been attributed to Archimedes but may well be invented by someone else – who knows …? So many bright minds were around in the days of Hellenism, and even in the early Roman times. Many of these people are only known by name because no written record – except maybe the title of their work – survives. But for many, even their names are lost.
      It would be interesting to speculate about how much of today’s ‘knowledge’ will still be around two thousand years from now. How much of our digital world will still be useful and workable then? Maybe not much …
      As you know, in history, yesterday’s truth may no longer be true today.

      Delete
    2. The main problem is how can you tell from a little wheel which mechanism it belonged to and who did it? why it couldn't have been built Ctesibius of Alexandria?
      A papyrus called "Laterculi Alexandrini" contain a list of the men who had reached the
      pinnacle of fame in various fields. The categories considered are those of
      legislators, painters, sculptors, architects and mechanics. The selection is so severe that among the sculptors they are only nominated
      Phidias, Scopas, Praxiteles, Myron and Polykleitos. It is evidently a
      “canon”, which intends to consecrate the summits of human genius.
      Among the mechanics he is named
      Abdaraxo, “builder of the machines of Alexandria”. It had to be about
      machines that were so famous at the time that the author of the Laterculi had deemed useless
      any further specification. Yet we have no other Greek source either
      Latin who has handed down the name of Abdaraxo, nor provided any clue for
      understand which machines the text refers to.
      Anyway who tells us that the Olbia mechanism was not built by Abdaraxo (or by the many others hellenistic mechanics now forgotten)?

      Delete